By: Gerard Shirar
Publisher: iUniverse
Publication Date: December 2017
ISBN: 978-1532036699
Reviewed by: Barbara Bamberger Scott
Review Date: December 20, 2018
Sometimes the law of the land gives way to the law of the jungle; in this gripping crime novel, author Gerard Shirar shows both, up close and at times, very ugly.
Timothy Flaherty and Donny Faye were friends all through elementary and high school, their main link being sports. Timmy knew Donny was different from him – sometimes he had marks on his face, like he’d been hit, and he never talked about his home life. That only seemed to make the bond stronger.
When both young men are drafted and sent to Vietnam straight out of high school, that link is broken for years, as Flaherty goes to college and becomes an attorney while Donny turns to crime. And not just any crime. With nothing to lose after a dishonorable discharge from the military, he gets “work” with Percy Dwyer, a criminal overlord who needs a guy like Donny – to kill people who get in Dwyer’s way. Faye and Flaherty are destined to meet again, when Faye finds himself framed by his pitiless boss.
Told in two parts, Shirar’s narrative doesn’t spare any nerve endings. Faye’s life path as recorded by Flaherty began when his brutal father told him he was “an accident.” Faye goes on to justify his own cold savagery with the street-wise logic that “I only did to him what he would have done to me.” Even when he tries to confess, a priest will not absolve him, so he gives up on religion, relying instead on something called “Him” who might be God, an angel or the devil. Flaherty meanwhile is learning the multi-layered morality of the legal profession that can involve cutting deals while making life-or-death decisions – no more crucial than when he finds himself defending his old friend, whose sins are many, and hard to stomach. The dilemma he faces as a lawyer - and as a human being - is whether there is a good choice, and whether he will make it.
Shirar, as an Army veteran and former attorney, has walked some of the walk he so intently details. He writes with admirable confidence, not a word out of place. His story hinges on the teetering balance between two versions of justice. In the first half of the book, we see how a man can be degraded without becoming a total monster, and in the second, how a man may, when called upon, do the wrong deed for the right reason. The reader can readily visualize the ambience Shirar so vividly depicts, from the gloomy underworld peopled by street thugs to the lofty and sometimes conflicted realms of legal power.
Quill says: Readers will find themselves picturing Shirar’s When the Rules Don’t Apply as a gritty, noire film, and will hope to see more output from this talented wordsmith.
Pulse of My Heart: A Gallagher Novel
Honolulu Heat: Between the Mountains and the Great Sea
Go Home, Afton (Book 1 in the Afton Morrison Series)
Sniper: A Frank Renzi Crime Thriller
Urban Limit: They are already inside...
The Amazon Detective Agency: A Murder Novel
Written Off (Forensic Handwriting Mystery Book 7)
The Double-Edged Sword (Tallent & Lowery Book 5)
A Deadly Éclair: A French Bistro Mystery
Dog Dish of Doom: An Agent to the Paws Mystery
A Measure of Murder: A Sally Solari Mystery
Lights Out Summer (A Coleridge Taylor Mystery)
The Last Train (Detective Hiroshi series, Book 1)
Opry: A Semi-Musical Tale of Honky Tonk Lifestyle
Dead Spider (A Loon Lake Mystery Series)
The Graves: Book 2 in the Abby Endicott series
News: A Tale of Too Much Information and a Girl
A Fatal Twist (A Downward Dog Mystery)
Natalie's Dilemma: A Frank Renzi Crime Thriller
A Lady’s Code of Misconduct (Rules for the Reckless)
The Gail Force: A Jake Travis Novel
Double Talk: A Warren Kingsley Mystery
A Black Sail: A Coleridge Taylor Mystery
Lawyer for the Cat: A Sally Baynard Novel
When Bunnies Go Bad: A Pru Marlowe Pet Noir
Her Forever Hero (Unexpected Heroes)
Karma's a Killer (A Downward Dog Mystery)
Nightmares Can be Murder: A Dream Club Mystery
The Puffin of Death: A Gunn Zoo Mystery
Florist Grump: A Flower Shop Mystery
Unleashed: A Kate Turner, DVM Mystery
A Curious Beginning: A Veronica Speedwell Mystery
Just You Wait: A Grace Street Mystery
Dream a Little Scream: A Dream Club Mystery
Beyond Suspicion: A Whispering Springs Mystery
High Country Nocturne: A David Mapstone Mystery
Fatal Reservations: A Key West Food Critic Mystery
Quick Pivot: A Joe Gale Mystery
Drop Dead Punk: Coleridge Taylor Mystery
Resorting to Murder: Holiday Mysteries, A British Library Crime Classic
Café Europa: An Edna Ferber Mystery
Purl Up and Die: A Knitting Mystery
A Fatal Chapter: A Booktown Mystery
Undercover Bride: Undercover Ladies series
Murder in Piccadilly: A British Library Crime Classic
The Sussex Downs Murder: A British Library Crime Classic
Kittens Can Kill: A Pru Marlowe Pet Noir
Death of a Diva: From Berlin to Broadway
Night Is the Hunter: A Harlan Donnally Novel
Butterfly Kills: A Stonechild and Rouleau Mystery
Saint Odd: An Odd Thomas Novel
High Stakes: A Jack Doyle Mystery
With Baited Breath: The Lotus Bay Mysteries
Mr. Samuel's Penny: An Elizabeth Parrot Landers Mystery
Natalie’s Art: Frank Renzi Book 5
Doghouse: A Gin & Tonic Mystery
The Book Stops Here: A Bibliophile Mystery
The Good Know Nothing: A California Century Mystery
The Second Coming: A Love Story
Dead Float: A Cal Claxton Mystery
Vengeance is Mine: A Red River Mystery
Final Curtain: An Edna Ferber Mystery
Hell With the Lid Blown Off: An Alafair Tucker Mystery
Book Clubbed (A Booktown Mystery)
This Private Plot: An Oliver Swithin Mystery
Reckless Disregard: A Parker Stern Novel
Face Value: A Rachel Gold Mystery
The Charlatan’s Crown: Tallent & Lowery, Book Four
Muzzled: A Kate Turner, DVM, Mystery
Panthers Play for Keeps: A Pru Marlowe Pet Mystery
The Hunger and the Howling of Killian Lone: The Secret Ingredient of Unforgettable Food Is Suffering
Here We Go Again - Short Story Collection
Light Riders and the Fleur-de-lis Murder
The Cat, the Devil and Lee Fontana
Murder with Ganache: A Key West Food Critic Mystery
Just Like Heaven: A Sweetland Novel
Throw in the Trowel: A Flower Shop Mystery
Light Riders and the Missouri Mud Murder
Dark Waters: A Jeff Resnick Mystery
Cold Tuscan Stone: A Rick Montoya Italian Mystery
Declan’s Cross (Sharpe & Donovan)
First-Degree Fudge: A Fudge Shop Mystery
Close Knit Killer: A Knitting Mystery
Downtown Strut: An Edna Ferber Mystery
Not the Killing Type: A Booktown Mystery
Seed No Evil: A Flower Shop Mystery
Do or Diner: A Comfort Food Mystery
The Diva Frosts a Cupcake: A Domestic Diva Mystery
Hex on the Ex: A Mind for Murder Mystery
The Cat, the Mill and the Murder: A Cats in Trouble Mystery
Cat Nap: A Sunny & Shadow Mystery
Bowled Over: A Vintage Kitchen Mystery
Trouble in the Tarot: A Fortune Teller Mystery
Braking Points: A Kate Reilly Mystery
Assaulted Pretzel: An Amish Mystery
A Fete Worse Than Death: A Hemlock Falls Mystery
The Bull Slayer: A Plinius Secundus Mystery
Wave Good-bye: Southern Beauty Shop
The Christie Curse: A Book Collector Mystery
Chance of a Ghost: A Haunted Guesthouse Mystery
The Sapphire Storm: Tallent & Lowery, Book Two
Night Terrors: A Daniel Rinaldi Mystery
Veiled Revenge: A Crime of Fashion Mystery
To Brie or Not to Brie: A Cheese Shop Mystery
Oodles of Poodles: A Pet Rescue Mystery
Every Trick in the Book: A Novel Idea Mystery
Holy Smoke: A Jerusalem Mystery
Town in a Pumpkin Bash: A Candy Holliday Murder Mystery
Knot What it Seams: A Southern Quilting Mystery
Out of Circulation: A Cat in the Stacks Mystery
Buried in a Bog: A County Cork Mystery
One Hot Murder: Victoria Square Mystery
Cat Trick: A Magical Cats Mystery
A Plain Scandal: An Appleseed Creek Mystery
The Llama of Death: A Gunn Zoo Mystery
If Hooks Could Kill: A Crochet Mystery
Arsenic and Old Cake: A Piece of Cake Mystery
Murder is a Piece of Cake: Josie Marcus, Mystery Shopper
Unbridled Greed: Money is the Motive - Fraud is the Means
Collared: A Gin & Tonic Mystery
Let It Sew: Southern Sewing Circle Mysteries
Wedding Cake Killer: A Fresh-Baked Mystery
A Novel Way to Die: A Black Cat Bookshop Mystery
The Clue is in the Pudding: A Special Pennyfoot Hotel Mystery
Nightshade on Elm Street: A Flower Shop Mystery
The Twelve Clues of Christmas: A Royal Spyness Mystery
I Saw Zombies Eating Santa Claus: A Breathers Christmas Carol
Murder of the Cat's Meow: A Scumble River Mystery
The Prodigal Son: A Carmine Delmonico Novel
Died with a Bow: An Accessories Mystery
Bruja Brouhaha: A Mind for Murder Mystery
How to Tail a Cat: A Cats and Curios Mystery
Murder Unmentionable: A Sweet Nothings Lingerie Mystery
Death in Four Courses: A Key West Food Critic Mystery
Mixed Signals: A Grace Street Mystery
Foul Play at the Fair: Celebration Bay Mystery
Natalie’s Revenge: A Frank Renzi Novel
Last Wool and Testament: A Haunted Yarn Shop Mystery
Allergic to Death: A Gourmet De-lite Mystery
Blood Bath & Beyond: An Immortality Bites Mystery
A Spoonful of Murder: A Soup Lover's Mystery
Murder Takes Time: Friendship and Honor Series, Book 1
Face of the Enemy: A New York in Wartime Mystery
When the Cookie Crumbles: A Cookie Cutter Shop Mystery
A Witch Before Dying: A Wishcraft Mystery
The Sauvignon Secret: A Wine Country Mystery
Sour Apples: An Orchard Mystery
Peril in Paperback: A Bibliophile Mystery
Murder for Choir: A Glee Club Mystery
Tahoe Trap: An Owen Mckenna Mystery Thriller
The Sins of the Father: Book 2, The Clifton Chronicles
Beef Stolen-Off: A Clueless Cook Mystery
In a Witch's Wardrobe: A Witchcraft Mystery
Murder on the Half Shelf: A Booktown Mystery
Pies and Prejudice: A Charmed Pie Shoppe Mystery
The Lost Artist: Five Star Mystery Series
Red Velvet Revenge: A Cupcake Bakery Mystery
Cloaked in Malice: A Vintage Magic Mystery
Hot Button: Button Box Mystery
Bound by Suggestion: The Jeff Resnick Mysteries
Dead Man Waltzing: A Ballroom Dance Mystery
Hearse and Buggy: An Amish Mystery
The Black Stiletto: Black & White
The Conviction: A David Sloan Novel
The Skeleton Box: A Starvation Lake Mystery
Threaded for Trouble: A Threadville Mystery
Quilt or Innocence: A Southern Quilting Mystery
The Azalea Assault: A Garden Society Mystery
The Second-Last Woman in England
The Diva Digs Up the Dirt: A Domestic Diva Mystery
Grace Among Thieves: A Manor House Mystery
A Plain Death: An Appleseed Creek Mystery
The Cat, the Wife and the Weapon: A Cats in Trouble Mystery
The Paris Directive: An Inspector Mazarelle Novel
Such Wicked Friends (Sandy Reid Mystery Series)
The Nightmare (A Mystery With Mary Wollstonecraft)
How to Get a Literary Agent, In Two Murders or Less
Blotto, Twinks and the Dead Dowager Duchess
Cat Telling Tales: A Joe Grey Mystery
Ghost Files: The Collected Cases From Ghost Hunting and Seeking Spirits
Sleight of Paw: A Magical Cats Mystery
All the Pretty Hearses: A Bed-and-Breakfast Mystery
Night and Day (A Jesse Stone Novel)
Pecan Gap: A Jake Somers Mystery
Chalk Line: A Ben Gallagher Mystery
Vintage Connor: The Blonde in the Lotus Elite
13 Million Dollar Pop: A Frank Behr Novel
Unraveled (A Knitting Mystery)
Sentenced to Death (A Booktown Mystery)
Pack of Lies (Book II: Paranormal Scene Investigations)
Dead Men Do Tell Tales: 60 Mini-Mysteries to Test Your Detective Prowess
In the Garden of Beasts: Love, Terror, and an American Family in Hitler's Berlin
Unprotected Love (Book 3 in the Lieutenant Denny Delaney series)
The Cat, the Lady and the Liar: A Cats in Trouble Mystery
Ultimate Revenge: Involuntary Transsexual
The Corruptible: A Ray Quinn Mystery
Blotto, Twinks, and the Ex-King's Daughter
Death By Wall Street: Rampage of the Bulls
End Game: Irrational Acts, Tragic Consequences
Did Not Survive: A Zoo Mystery
Bitter Legacy (A Matt Royal Mystery)
v2036: A Tale of Sociopolitical Change in a Militarized Venezuela
Unfinished Business: Pursuit of an Antarctic Killer
Frozen in Time: Murder at the Bottom of the World
The Spider’s Web (A Wind River Reservation Mystery)
Love Bites (Vampyres of Hollywood)
Scoop to Kill: A Mystery a La Mode
Cheated by Death: A Jeff Resnick Mystery
Vows, Vendettas and a Little Black Dress
The Cat, the Professor and the Poison: A Cats in Trouble Mystery
Pride and Prejudice and Zombies: Dawn of the Dreadfuls
Stranger In Paradise (A Jesse Stone Novel)
Dead of Knight: A Jack Staal Mystery
Bookplate Special (A Booktown Mystery)
Disclosure in Accordance with FTC Guidelines 16 CFR Part 255
Copyrights © 2019 Feathered Quill Reviews All Rights Reserved. | Designed & Developed by 8 Create